Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie: An Easy Recipe for a Timeless, Creamy Delight
Step into the heart of Southern hospitality with a slice of classic Southern Buttermilk Pie. This beloved vintage dessert is a true testament to the beauty of simple ingredients coming together to create something extraordinary. Imagine a perfectly light golden crust cradling a rich, creamy, and wonderfully tender custard-like filling. With its sweet hints of tang and comforting warmth, this pie is not just a treat for the taste buds, but a taste of tradition. What makes it even better? You can have it prepped and ready for the oven in less than 15 minutes, making it an ideal choice for both seasoned bakers and eager beginners looking for a quick yet impressive homemade dessert.
Why This Southern Buttermilk Pie Recipe Is a Must-Try
This Southern Buttermilk Pie isn’t just another dessert; it’s a culinary experience that has stood the test of time, cherished for its unique characteristics and delightful simplicity. It masterfully bridges the gap between a traditional custard pie and a bright lemon pie, offering a harmonious blend of sweet and tangy flavors. The secret to its irresistible appeal lies in its incredibly creamy texture, a testament to the magic that happens when humble ingredients are combined with care. This pie offers a comforting indulgence that’s surprisingly easy to achieve, making it a staple in Southern kitchens and a delightful discovery for anyone new to its charms.
The beauty of this recipe is its straightforward approach. You won’t need a lengthy list of exotic items or specialized equipment. It relies on everyday pantry staples like fresh eggs, granulated sugar, all-purpose flour, rich butter, and pure vanilla extract. The distinctive lightly tangy flavor, which truly defines a buttermilk pie, comes from the star ingredients: fresh lemon juice, aromatic lemon zest, and, of course, the creamy buttermilk itself. These elements work in concert to create a flavor profile that is both complex and deeply satisfying. Whether you opt for a convenient store-bought pie crust for ultimate ease or enjoy the process of making your own from scratch – you can find our detailed homemade crust recipe in our apple pie post – this pie promises a rich, satisfying reward for minimal effort. Its quick prep time (under 15 minutes) means you can whip up this elegant dessert even on a busy weeknight, proving that delicious, homemade treats are always within reach. The result is a pie with a tender, golden crust and a filling that’s perfectly set yet melts in your mouth, leaving a lingering taste of sweet, tangy goodness.
Essential Ingredients for Your Buttermilk Pie
Crafting this classic Southern Buttermilk Pie requires a few simple, wholesome ingredients that are likely already in your kitchen. While the full list of precise measurements and detailed instructions can be found in the printable recipe card at the bottom of this post, here’s a quick overview of what you’ll need to gather to begin your baking adventure:
You’ll combine large, room-temperature eggs, granulated sugar, all-purpose flour for thickening, melted and cooled salted butter for richness, tangy buttermilk, fresh lemon juice and vibrant lemon zest for that signature flavor, and pure vanilla extract to deepen the overall taste. These components, when carefully blended, create the signature creamy, tangy, and tender filling that buttermilk pie is famous for. For the foundation of your pie, an unbaked 9-inch pie crust is essential – whether you choose the convenience of a good quality store-bought crust or the satisfaction of a homemade version. Each ingredient plays a crucial role in achieving the perfect balance of flavor and texture that makes this pie so irresistible.
Ingredient Spotlight & Expert Substitution Tips
Understanding each ingredient’s role and knowing possible substitutions can elevate your baking confidence and help you achieve consistent results every time. Here’s a deeper look into the components of your Southern Buttermilk Pie, along with some helpful tips:
CRUST – For maximum convenience and a speedy path to dessert, we often recommend a reliable store-bought 9-inch refrigerated pie crust. These are readily available in most grocery stores and provide a perfectly crisp base without the extra effort of dough preparation. However, if you have a cherished homemade pie crust recipe or simply prefer the satisfaction of baking from scratch, feel free to use your own. A flaky, buttery homemade crust adds an extra layer of love and bespoke flavor that is truly unbeatable. Whichever you choose, ensure the crust is unbaked when you pour in the filling.
FILLING – The heart of this pie lies in its delightful custard filling, where a few key ingredients create its characteristic taste and texture.
- Buttermilk: This is the star ingredient, responsible for the pie’s signature light tang and tender crumb. Buttermilk’s acidity reacts with baking soda (though not explicitly in this recipe, it’s a general principle that creates tenderness in baked goods) to contribute to the pie’s delicate texture. If you don’t have buttermilk on hand, don’t fret! You can easily make your own substitute by adding 1 tablespoon of fresh lemon juice or white vinegar to a liquid measuring cup, then filling the rest with regular milk (dairy or non-dairy works) until it reaches 1 cup. Let it sit for 5-10 minutes until it slightly curdles – this is your homemade buttermilk. While regular buttermilk is generally recommended for the best flavor and consistency, low-fat buttermilk can be used as a lighter alternative without significantly altering the final outcome.
- Lemon Zest and Lemon Juice: These two components provide the bright, zesty counterpoint to the sweetness of the pie. The lemon juice contributes a refreshing, sharp tang, while the zest infuses the custard with a vibrant, aromatic citrus flavor that lifts the entire dish. For the freshest and most impactful taste, we highly recommend using a fresh lemon for both its juice and zest, rather than relying on store-bought bottled lemon juice, which can sometimes taste less vibrant and more artificial.
- Granulated Sugar: Sugar is not just for sweetness; it plays a crucial role in the pie’s structure and helps achieve that beautifully golden crust. The amount specified in the recipe is carefully chosen for a classic, balanced flavor profile. If you’re looking to reduce the sugar content for dietary reasons, you can certainly experiment, but be aware that significantly reducing it may slightly alter the pie’s texture, setting ability, and browning.
- Eggs: Eggs are absolutely crucial for creating the custard’s smooth structure and rich, creamy texture. They act as a binder and thickener, ensuring the filling sets beautifully when baked. For the best and most consistent results, always use large eggs at room temperature, as they emulsify more easily with the other ingredients, leading to a smoother, more homogenous filling without lumps.
- All-Purpose Flour: A small amount of all-purpose flour helps to slightly thicken the custard, giving it that wonderfully tender yet set consistency. It prevents the pie from becoming too liquidy and ensures it holds its shape perfectly once cooled, allowing for clean slices.
- Salted Butter: Melted and cooled butter adds a luxurious richness and a subtle savory depth that enhances the overall flavor profile of the pie. It’s imperative that the butter is cooled to room temperature before being added to the egg mixture. Adding hot butter could inadvertently scramble the eggs or create an uneven texture. If you only have unsalted butter, simply add a tiny pinch of salt (about 1/8 teaspoon) to the filling to balance the flavors.
- Vanilla Extract: A tablespoon of good quality vanilla extract deepens the flavor profile, adding warmth, aroma, and complexity to the pie. Pure vanilla extract is always preferred over imitation for the most authentic and delicious taste.
- Optional Flavor Enhancements: For those who enjoy a bit of extra warmth and spice, a pinch of freshly grated nutmeg can be a delightful addition, offering a subtle earthiness that complements the creamy filling. Alternatively, for a more adult and sophisticated twist, a tablespoon or two of bourbon or rum can introduce a rich, nuanced depth of flavor, making your pie truly unique and even more delicious. These additions are entirely optional but highly recommended for adventurous bakers!
Baking Your Perfect Southern Buttermilk Pie: Step-by-Step Guide
These step-by-step photos and instructions are designed to help you visualize each stage of making this delectable recipe, ensuring your baking process is smooth and successful. For a convenient printable version, complete with precise measurements and comprehensive instructions, simply Jump to Recipe at the bottom of this post.
- Prepare Your Oven: Begin by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). This crucial first step ensures that your oven is at the correct temperature from the start, which is vital for even baking and achieving a perfectly set custard without overbaking the edges.
- Whisk the Eggs: In the clean bowl of a standing mixer fitted with the whisk attachment (or using a hand beater for convenience), crack your three large, room-temperature eggs. Whisk them thoroughly at a medium-high speed until they become light, pale, and noticeably frothy. This aeration is key to a tender, smooth, and light custard.
- Combine Dry Ingredients with Eggs: Add the granulated sugar and all-purpose flour to the whisked eggs in the bowl. Continue to beat the mixture on medium speed until all the dry ingredients are fully incorporated and the batter appears smooth and lump-free. Make sure to stop and scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl frequently with a rubber spatula to ensure that everything is evenly mixed and no pockets of unmixed flour or sugar remain. This step is important for a consistent custard texture.
- Incorporate the Butter: Gently beat in the melted and *cooled* salted butter. It’s vital that the butter is at room temperature or slightly cooler (not hot!) to prevent it from accidentally scrambling the eggs or altering the smooth consistency of the batter. Mix until the butter is just combined and no streaks remain.
- Add Wet Ingredients & Flavorings: Pour in the buttermilk, fresh lemon juice, vibrant lemon zest, and the rich vanilla extract into the bowl. Beat the entire mixture for approximately 1 minute longer on medium-low speed. This final whisking ensures all the tangy, sweet, and aromatic components are perfectly blended into a silky-smooth filling, ready for baking.
- Fill the Pie Crust: Carefully pour the prepared buttermilk filling into your chosen 9-inch unbaked pie crust. Ensure the crust is neatly crimped or fluted around the edges for a beautiful presentation and to help contain the filling during baking.
- Bake to Perfection: Place the filled pie in your preheated oven and bake for 35-40 minutes. The key to knowing when it’s done is observing the center of the pie: it should be nearly set. When gently nudged, the pie will still have a slight jiggly motion throughout (like firm Jell-O), but the very center should not appear runny or liquid. To prevent the pie crust edges from over-browning or burning, which can happen quickly, it’s a good practice to cover them with strips of aluminum foil or a reusable pie crust shield after the initial 15-20 minutes of baking, once they’ve achieved a lovely golden brown color.
- Cool Completely: This step is paramount for achieving the ideal creamy, set texture! Once baked, carefully remove the pie from the oven and allow it to cool completely on a wire rack before attempting to slice and serve. Cooling is absolutely essential for the custard to fully set and firm up, ensuring you get perfect, clean slices every time. Resist the temptation to cut into it early – patience here will be rewarded with the ideal creamy texture.
- Serve and Enjoy: For an ultimate indulgence, serve your cooled Southern Buttermilk Pie with a generous dollop of fresh whipped cream. The light, airy cream provides a perfect textural and flavor contrast to the rich, tangy custard, making each bite a heavenly experience.
Frequently Asked Questions & Expert Baking Tips
No, a properly baked buttermilk pie should definitely not be runny. When you first remove it from the oven, the center might still have a slight, delicate jiggle – this is normal and indicates it’s just on the cusp of being perfectly set, as it will continue to firm up with residual heat. However, as it cools completely to room temperature, the custard will firm up and achieve a smooth, creamy, and tender consistency, similar to a classic baked custard. If your pie remains overly runny after cooling, it’s typically a sign of incorrect ingredient measurements or, most commonly, that it simply needed more time to bake in the oven. An underbaked pie will fail to set, so always ensure the center is mostly firm and just slightly jiggly before removing it, and allow ample cooling time.
Due to its custard base, Southern Buttermilk Pie contains dairy and eggs, so it should always be stored in the refrigerator to maintain its freshness and safety. To prevent it from drying out or absorbing other flavors from your fridge, place the cooled pie in an airtight container or cover it tightly with several layers of plastic wrap. Stored this way, your delicious pie will remain fresh and enjoyable for up to 3 days. For best flavor and texture, many enjoy it chilled, but you can also allow it to come to room temperature for about 15-20 minutes before serving if preferred.
Yes, buttermilk pie freezes remarkably well, making it an excellent option for meal prepping, enjoying later, or extending its shelf life. To freeze, first ensure the pie has completely cooled to room temperature, which is essential to prevent ice crystals. Then, wrap it thoroughly with several layers of plastic wrap, followed by an additional layer of heavy-duty aluminum foil. This double wrapping helps to prevent freezer burn and preserves its delicate texture and flavor. You can safely freeze the pie for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to enjoy it, simply thaw the pie overnight in the refrigerator. Once thawed, it’s almost as good as fresh, ready to be sliced and served.
While often compared due to their Southern origins and custard-like fillings, Buttermilk Pie and Chess Pie have distinct characteristics. Both are traditional Southern custard pies, but Chess Pie typically includes cornmeal in its filling, which gives it a slightly coarser, sometimes grainy texture and helps create a “crust” on top (the origin of “chess” is debated, possibly derived from “cheese” in old recipes, or referring to “pie chest”). Chess Pie also frequently contains vinegar, which enhances its tangy profile and contributes to its firm setting. Buttermilk Pie, on the other hand, is renowned for its silky-smooth, almost delicate custard consistency, achieving its tang primarily from buttermilk and lemon without the addition of cornmeal or, typically, vinegar.
Cracks in the surface of a buttermilk pie are usually caused by overbaking or cooling too quickly. When a custard pie bakes for too long, the proteins in the eggs tighten excessively, causing the custard to pull away from the sides of the crust and contract, leading to unsightly cracks. Rapid temperature changes during cooling, such as moving a hot pie directly into a cold refrigerator or placing it in a very drafty area, can also contribute to cracking. To minimize cracking, ensure you remove the pie from the oven when it still has a slight, central jiggle (it will continue to set as it cools) and let it cool gradually and completely on a wire rack at room temperature, away from sudden temperature shifts.
Absolutely! Buttermilk pie is an excellent make-ahead dessert, making it perfect for entertaining or holiday meals. Its flavors actually deepen and meld beautifully after a day or two in the refrigerator, allowing the tang and sweetness to fully develop. Prepare, bake, and cool the pie completely, then cover it tightly with plastic wrap or store it in an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 3 days. This thoughtful planning means you can have a delicious homemade dessert ready without any last-minute stress, leaving you more time to enjoy your guests or family.
Delightful Serving Suggestions for Buttermilk Pie
A slice of Southern Buttermilk Pie is utterly delicious on its own, showcasing its comforting, tangy-sweet custard filling and tender crust. Its simple elegance truly shines with every bite. However, for an elevated dessert experience that truly impresses, it pairs exquisitely with a variety of accompaniments. The classic and most popular choice is a generous dollop of freshly whipped cream. Its light, airy texture and subtle sweetness provide a wonderful contrast to the dense, creamy, and tangy filling. For an extra touch of sophistication, you can sweeten the whipped cream with a hint of vanilla bean paste, a touch of powdered sugar, or even a tiny amount of complementary citrus zest.
For a burst of fresh flavor and vibrant color, consider serving your pie with an assortment of fresh berries. Juicy blueberries, sweet strawberries, or slightly tart raspberries, or even a medley of all three, add a lovely natural tartness and juicy freshness that beautifully cuts through the richness of the pie. A light dusting of powdered sugar over the top of the pie can also add a touch of simple elegance and a slight sweetness to the presentation. This versatile pie is always a welcome addition to any dessert spread, whether it’s a casual family dinner, a festive holiday celebration like Thanksgiving or Christmas, or a special gathering with friends. It brings a taste of authentic Southern charm and comforting nostalgia to every occasion, proving to be a beloved crowd-pleaser that guests will rave about.
Explore More Irresistible Pie Recipes
If you’ve fallen in love with the comforting charm of homemade pies, whether for their flaky crusts, rich fillings, or nostalgic appeal, we have plenty more delectable recipes for you to discover. From vibrant fruity delights to decadent, rich, and creamy confections, our extensive collection offers a pie for every palate and every occasion. Broaden your baking horizons and find your next favorite dessert among these enticing options that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth:
- Classic Blueberry Pie
- Decadent French Silk Pie
- Creamy Banana Cream Pie
- Heartwarming Homemade Apple Pie
- Easy No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie
- The Perfect Pumpkin Pie Recipe
- Comforting Sweet Potato Pie
I love to bake and cook and share my kitchen experience with all of you! Remembering to come back each day can be tough, that’s why I offer a convenient newsletter every time a new recipe posts. Simply subscribe and start receiving your free daily recipes!
Southern Buttermilk Pie
IMPORTANT – There are often Frequently Asked Questions within the blog post that you may find helpful. Simply scroll back up to read them!
Print It
Pin It
Rate It
Save ItSaved!
Ingredients
- 3 large eggs at room temperature
- 1 ¼ cup granulated sugar
- 4 Tbsp all-purpose flour
- ½ cup salted butter 1 stick, melted and cooled
- 1 cup buttermilk
- 2 Tbsp lemon juice
- zest of one lemon
- 1 Tbsp vanilla extract
- 1 9 inch pie crust unbaked
Things You’ll Need
-
9 inch pie pan
-
Stand mixer
Before You Begin
- Sometimes people add a bit of nutmeg and/or bourbon/rum to the buttermilk pie for an extra layer of flavor.
- Buttermilk pie is similar to a chess pie, but a chess pie typically includes cornmeal in its filling for a slightly different texture and often vinegar for tang. Buttermilk pie has a consistency closer to a pure, silky custard.
- For the smoothest custard, ensure your eggs and buttermilk are at room temperature. This helps them incorporate more evenly into the mixture, preventing a curdled or uneven texture in the final pie.
- If you prefer a less sweet pie, you can slightly reduce the granulated sugar (by 1/4 cup, for instance), but avoid reducing it too drastically as sugar contributes to the pie’s structure and its beautiful golden-brown top.
Instructions
-
Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C).
-
In the bowl of a standing mixer (or with a hand beater), whisk 3 large eggs until frothy and pale.
-
Add 1 ¼ cup granulated sugar and 4 Tbsp all-purpose flour to the bowl and beat to combine thoroughly. Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl well to ensure even mixing and a smooth batter.
-
Beat in ½ cup of melted and cooled salted butter. Ensure the butter is cool to prevent cooking the eggs prematurely.
-
Add 1 cup buttermilk, 2 Tbsp lemon juice, the zest of one lemon, and 1 Tbsp vanilla extract to the bowl and beat for 1 minute longer until all ingredients are well combined and the mixture is smooth and cohesive.
-
Pour the prepared filling into a 9” unbaked pie crust.
-
Bake for 35-40 minutes, or until the center of the pie is nearly set. The pie will still be just slightly jiggly throughout (like a firm jelly), but the very center should not appear runny. To prevent the pie crust from burning, cover the edges with aluminum foil or a pie crust shield after the first 15-20 minutes of baking, once they are golden brown.
-
Cool pie completely on a wire rack before slicing and serving. This allows the custard to fully set and firm up, ensuring perfect slices.
-
Serve with fresh whipped cream for an added touch of indulgence, if desired.
Nutrition
The recipes on this blog are tested with a conventional gas oven and gas stovetop. It’s important to note that some ovens, especially as they age, can cook and bake inconsistently. Using an inexpensive oven thermometer can assure you that your oven is truly heating to the proper temperature. If you use a toaster oven or countertop oven, please keep in mind that they may not distribute heat the same as a conventional full sized oven and you may need to adjust your cooking/baking times. In the case of recipes made with a pressure cooker, air fryer, slow cooker, or other appliance, a link to the appliances we use is listed within each respective recipe. For baking recipes where measurements are given by weight, please note that results may not be the same if cups are used instead, and we can’t guarantee success with that method.